The Torch Magazine,
The Journal and Magazine of the
International Association of Torch Clubs
For 87 Years
A Peer-Reviewed
Quality Controlled
Publication
ISSN Print 0040-9440
ISSN Online 2330-9261
Spring
2014
Volume 87, Issue 3
Sweden's
Shattered Dream: The
Assassination of Olof Palme
and Contemporary Crime Novels
by Elaine Kruse
The first thing to
come to our American minds when we
think of Sweden may be Ikea, Abba, or
Dag Hammersjkold, or we may instead
recall The Girl with the Dragon
Tattoo or the BBC series
"Wallander," for Swedish crime fiction
has come to the fore since the 1960s.
Few Americans know, however, that a
traumatic and still unsolved
high-level political assassination
occurred in Sweden less than thirty
years ago. In 1986 the Prime Minister
of Sweden, Olof Palme, was
assassinated, and the killer has never
been found. Another prominent Social
Democrat, Anna Lindh, spoke at his
funeral, promising to keep faith with
Palme's vision: "With all our
resources we will carry on your
struggle. The struggle for
freedom, for international solidarity,
for a free and open Sweden, a Sweden
without racism and the fear of
Otherness." In 2003, when she
was Foreign Minister and potentially
the next Prime Minister, she was
stabbed in a shopping mall. A security
guard leaned over her and asked if she
though the attack was political. She
replied, "Of course, it's political"
(Everman 91).
The Palme
assassination shook the Swedish
self-image and brought about a new
national introspection. Suddenly,
Sweden seemed no longer to be the
stable, prosperous, open society the
world took it to be, and it took
itself to be.
The
reputation of an "innocent Sweden" was
based on its long-standing refusal to
take part in wars, dating back to
1814. Sweden never fought
directly in World War I and managed to
avoid joining sides or being invaded
in World War II. Prospering in the
30's and developing its trademark
socialism, Sweden boomed after the war
with its Swedish steel, paper, cars,
and telephones (Bondeson 1). Known as
the ideal socialist state, with
programs that provide for its citizens
from birth to death, Sweden also
welcomed victims of torture, most
recently the refugees from the Bosnian
war of the 1990s. Where had this
hatred and violence come from? This,
and other questions raised by a still
mysterious assassination, lay behind
the crime novels that have become an
international publishing phenomenon.
Olof Palme
Born in 1928 to a wealthy,
distinguished upper-class family,
Palme early displayed his intelligence
at an excellent private school. In
1947-48, he received a one-year
scholarship to Kenyon College in Ohio,
where he wrote his senior thesis on
the UAW, having interviewed Walter
Reuther and toured the auto plants
(Bondeson). He returned to Stockholm
University, where he took courses in
law and journalism and was soon
involved in student union politics. On
a train trip, he happened to meet and
impress Prime Minister Tage Erlander
of the ruling Social Democratic party;
by the age of twenty-five, he was
Erlander's indispensable parliamentary
secretary, lobbyist, speechwriter, and
political manager (Derfler 2-3).
Palme stood out
from other party leaders, speaking six
languages fluently, well-versed in
international as well as internal
affairs. His elite background and
sometimes arrogant ways made him
unpopular with many in his own party.
Conservatives hated him as a traitor
to their interests. At the time of his
assassination, many police and naval
officers despised him, seeing him as
an agent of the KGB.
Palme met his wife
at Lund University. Though coming from
a noble family, Lisbet Beck-Friis
shared his socialist views, and
together they lived frugally in a
small house. He washed dishes and did
the laundry, commuting to work on a
scooter. They had three sons and were
happily married.
When Palme became
minister of education in 1963, he
applied his socialist ideals,
extending the required years of
education to eleven or twelve years
and lowering university admission
standards to accommodate most
students, but it was in foreign policy
issues that he became most visible. In
1965, while Erlander was on vacation,
Palme gave his Gavle speech, stating
that the Social Democratic party
should side with the oppressed, that
is, the North Vietnamese. In
1968, when students were taking to the
streets and speaking out against the
Vietnam War, he walked side by side
with the North Vietnamese ambassador
to Moscow in a torchlight parade in
Stockholm and claimed more bombs had
been dropped on North Vietnam in the
past three years than on Nazi Germany
in the Second World War. Washington
recalled the American ambassador from
Stockholm to protest Palme's presence
at the demonstration. Sweden
recognized North Vietnam, the first
country to do so, and promised $40
million without preconditions.
On May 1, 1968,
Palme was joined by Greek actress
Melina Mercouri in the annual May Day
rally. Palme stated, "we
ourselves define the Swedish policy of
neutrality," that is, neutrality and
opposition to an American-led war were
not contradictory (Derfler, 14-15).
Such an image served Palme and
Sweden's security well, Robert Dalsjo
suggests:
"the
active foreign policy" of Sweden
included "barbs directed against the
United States" that changed
the image of Sweden from that of a
reticent and pro-Western neutral to
that of an outspoken and righteous
champion of peoples seeking
liberation from colonialism and
"U.S. imperialism." Thus, Sweden
distanced itself politically from
the West but also gained the moral
high ground. This had a positive
effect on self-perception:
neutrality merged with modernity and
the welfare state into something of
a national meta-ideology. Sweden now
had a happy syllogism: Being Swedish
was to be neutral, being neutral was
good, thus it was good to be a
Swede.
Palme was
denounced in the American press for
his outspoken attacks on the war,
though Senator Fulbright wrote him a
letter of support. Palme also
offered political asylum to American
youth who refused the draft.
Palme was playing a
dangerous game, criticizing American
foreign policy while secretly taking
their aid. As the Cold War had
escalated, Sweden, which claimed
neutrality and practiced
non-alignment, had been secretly
cooperating with the United States.
President Eisenhower had promised to
come to Sweden's defense in case of an
invasion. In return, Sweden allowed
the United States and its NATO allies
to secretly use Swedish air space and
coastal waters for submarine
espionage. This deal was known only to
a few at the top, including Palme. As
Leslie Derfler observes, "it raised
the stakes (of governmental survival)
should the truth about this reality
become known to the public" (16). But
there was more to come.
The Christmas
bombings of North Vietnam in 1972 led
to Palme's controversial Christmas Eve
Declaration:
One
must call things by their
name. What's happening today
in Vietnam is a form of torture […].
What is perpetrated there is the
torture of human beings, the torture
of a nation to humiliate it, to
force it to surrender…That is why
the bombings are a crime. One
finds many similarities in modern
history—Guernica, Oradour, Babi Yar,
Katyn, Lidice, Sharpeville,
Treblinka. Violence has
triumphed. But the judgment of
history is severe for those
responsible. There is now another
name to add to that list:
Hanoi—Christmas, 1972.
Palme's
statement enraged the Nixon
administration, creating another
crisis in Swedish-American
relations. Conservatives asked
Palme to withdraw his declaration, but
he refused. Each of these three open
stands against American policy in
Vietnam drew admiration and hostility,
respect and suspicion. Palme
viewed them as the moments in his life
he was most proud of (Derfler 23).
In 1969, Palme took
over as Prime Minister, succeeding his
mentor, Erlander. As Prime Minister,
Palme played on the idea of Sweden as
"the People's Home," where social
classes were eliminated, all were
equal, poverty had disappeared, and
people were taken care of by the state
from cradle to grave. The cost
of such a program was heavy taxation
and a massive bureaucracy.
Conditions in
Sweden were critiqued not only by the
political opposition, but also by the
"reigning king and queen of mystery
fiction" as they were called, Maj
Sjowall and Per Wahloo, a husband and
wife team. Their novels became known
for their psychological analysis of
both detective and perpetrator and for
the way they mirrored society,
chronicling police brutality and a
failing social system. As Marxists,
they were critical of the Security
Police (SAPO)'s obsession with finding
Communists and its disregard of the
dangers of fascist capitalists; they
depicted the police system as ruined
by the state takeover and bureaucratic
stupidity.
The Terrorists,
the tenth and final volume of their
series (published in 1975, the same
year Wahloo died of a heart attack),
echoed the fear of terrorism
worldwide, with assassinations of
persons from all political stances
becoming more frequent. It also
contains a satirical portrait of the
Prime Minister:
The
Prime Minister was a slightly edgy,
nervous type, with effeminate and
slightly sorrowful features.
Whatever he radiated, it was not the
paternalism for which some of his
predecessors had been known and
adored. Those who had tried to
analyze in depth his appearance and
behavior maintained there was clear
evidence of a guilty conscience and
childish disappointment. (Sjowall
and Wahloo 188-89)
In the novel,
Sjowall and Wahloo's detective Martin
Beck outwits the terrorists planning
to kill the Prime Minister, but a
young woman who had been treated badly
by the system manages to shoot the
Prime Minister at close range and kill
him.
Eleven years later,
Palme was walking home from a movie
with his wife when he was killed by an
unknown assassin.
The Assassination
What was the context for the
assassination? Palme had become a
prominent figure in international
politics. He encouraged Western
countries to work with the Third
World, decrying the neo-colonialism of
American and Russian policies. His
support of Castro's Cuba and the
communist regime in Nicaragua led to
him being denounced in the US as a
communist and agent of the KGB. An
international leader in the resurgence
of the Socialist International, he
denounced apartheid in South Africa
and became known for his advocacy of
peace, disarmament, and redistribution
of wealth.
Palme
dominated Swedish domestic
politics as well. In 1972, the Swedish
paper Dagens Nyheter wrote, "Sweden
has, not the Palme government, but
Palme. Almost everything revolves
around him, the negative and the
positive" (quoted in Derfler 23).
Palme referred to his party's program
as "the renovation of the life of
labor." One reform followed
another: in 1974 a law favoring old
aged and handicapped workers; in 1975,
a law regulating conditions for
dismissal; in 1976, a law enabling
workers to participate in managerial
decisions. A plan to invest wage
earner funds in private enterprises,
however, proved politically difficult.
Events turned
against him in 1976. Amidst an
economic crisis, conservatives
criticized the centralization of power
and Palme's expansion of nuclear
energy; labor unions criticized his
handling of the wage earner funds
issue. The Social Democratic
party lost control of Parliament,
after 44 years of continuous
power. Palme spent the next six
years as opposition leader, returning
to power in 1982 after a campaign
based on the fear of conservative
limits on social legislation. He eased
up on taxes, accepted private
day-nurseries as an alternative to the
state run system, and watered down the
program for workers' funds invested in
their industries. Nevertheless,
his right-wing enemies hated him even
more.
On the evening of
the day Olof Palme was murdered,
February 28, 1986, he and his wife
went to the movies with their son and
his girlfriend. After the movie, he
and Lisbet headed home on foot,
despite the snowy streets and the cold
(-7 degrees Celsius), and without
bodyguards (he treasured his privacy
and disliked their presence)..
Witnesses say that they stopped to
look in the Dekorima store window and
were approached by a man standing
nearby. He grabbed Palme by the
shoulder, took out a gun and shot
Palme in the back, then turned the gun
on Lisbet, but only grazed her.
The murderer then ran quickly up an
89-step stairway and disappeared.
A witness called
the Swedish equivalent of 911 within
45 seconds, and the operator
transferred the call to the police,
but they did not pick up the phone and
he gave up. A cab driver called his
company and shouted, "Someone has just
been shot! Call the police and an
ambulance," but when the dispatcher
did, the detective failed to follow
standard procedures and instead
treated it like a potential hoax. When
another policeman alerted by a cab
driver arrived at the scene, Lisbet
was screaming hysterically. It
took five minutes before the police
realized the victim was the Prime
Minister. The response by the police
was so unprofessional that some have
posited that they were part of the
plot. Little evidence supports that
view. Nevertheless, clearly the police
investigation was botched:
policemen walked all over the murder
site, obliterating any footprints;
Palme's wife gave a description which
matched a witness, not the killer;
witnesses were not questioned; the
police built a case against a man who
proved to be innocent. The
murder has never been solved
(Bondeson, 2-38).
The assassination
of Olof Palme traumatized the nation,
and Sweden's image was irrevocably
altered. Five hundred thousand
people lined the route of the funeral
procession, a route drenched in the
color red. Fifteen heads of state, led
by France's Francois Mitterand,
seventeen prime ministers, and
fourteen foreign ministers, including
U.S. Secretary of State George Schulz,
attended (Derfler, 69). The civil
burial was organized and dominated by
the Social Democratic party; Leslie
Derfer writes, "the symbolism could
not have been more clear: the murdered
prime minister was carried to his
grave by his party, the Socialist
International, the UN, and the Third
World. The king and the nation
state were secondary" (69).
Palme and Swedish
Detective Fiction
Swedish detective
fiction has flourished since the Palme
murder. In many ways, it is haunted by
that murder, by the conflicts that
defined Palme's career, and by the
anxieties created by the murders still
being unsolved. Mistrust of the
state police, for instance, pervades
these books. In the novels of Sjowall
and Wahloo, Martin Beck has among the
police only one close friend, who
eventually resigns. They liken
one pair of policemen to the Keystone
cops, a subplot that emerges in
contemporary writers Henning Mankell
and Leif Persson's novels as well, in
which many policemen are depicted as
racist, homophobic, sexist, and
brutal. As is true in much
detective fiction, the powers on top
are pushing for a quick solution,
often running roughshod over the
evidence, echoing the behavior of the
police in the Palme case.
Henning Mankell's
Wallander novels tend to emphasize
social issues, such as the impact of
immigration and drug traffic. But the
last Wallander novel, The Troubled
Man, draws on the shadowy
history of Swedish involvement with
both the CIA and the KGB in the Cold
War years. Mankell raises the specter
of Swedish spies, recalling the
infamous Stig Wennerstrom, convicted
of spying for the Russians in 1964 and
sentenced to twenty years in prison,
but then freed after only ten.
The Troubled
Man opens in 1983, when the
detection of a submarine in Swedish
waters made Palme furious, but the
guilty country was never exposed. In
the novel's Prologue, Palme
shouts: "There is no proof. Only
claims, insinuations, nods and winks
from disloyal navy officers.
This investigation has shed light on
nothing at all. On the contrary,
it has left us wallowing in political
swamps." Years later, Wallander is
driven to uncover the true story of
the disappearance of a retired
submarine commander, who turns out to
have been a spy for the U.S.
Wallander learns that naval officers
had socialized regularly and denounced
Palme as a traitor, toasting his
assassin. In the Afterword, Mankell
writes, "I write in order to try to
make the world understandable. […] The
most important things in this book are
built on the solid foundation of
reality."
The late Stieg
Larsson, author of the hugely popular
series that began with The Girl
with the Dragon Tattoo, worked
as an investigative journalist,
leading to his emphasis on social and
political problems. Larsson used the
name Wennerstrom (though with a
Christian name different from that of
the real-life spy) for the
industrialist running an empire based
on sex trafficking, drug running, and
Mafia connections that is exposed by
his protagonist, Mikael Blomkvist. The
wealthy family in the novel, the
Vangers, includes torturers, rapists,
and killers of women. Blomkvist's
aide, Lisbeth Salander—the girl with
the dragon tattoo—had been
incarcerated for years in an insane
asylum and sexually molested by her
appointed "guardian." Larsson had just
turned in his three novels to his
publisher when his life tragically
ended. He had asked for police
protection from the Neo-Nazis,
particularly because he was scheduled
to give a talk on their activity on
the day he died. Larsson died of
a heart attack at the age of 47 after
climbing up seven floors in his
apartment building when the elevator
wouldn't work. One might wonder
what really caused his "heart attack."
A trilogy of novels
centering on the Palme assassination,
highly popular in Sweden, has been
published by Leif G.W. Persson over
the last ten years. In the first
novel, Between Summer's Longing
and Winter's End, Persson
postulates that Palme was murdered by
an agent of the Swedish secret police,
SAPO, who believed that Palme was a
Russian spy and traitor. But in
a surprise ending, the CIA is part of
the deception of the Swedish police.
In the second novel, Another Time, Another Life
Persson continues his depiction of the
Swedish secret security police as
"lazy, stupid, bigoted, greedy corrupt
idiots" (Stasio) and hints that the
assassination still needs to be
solved.
So, who did kill
Olof Palme, and why? One hundred forty
inspectors and policemen, led by Hans
Holmer, chief of the Stockholm police,
were assigned to find the killer. They
got nowhere, at one time arresting and
trying a derelict, whose conviction
was later overturned. I have a
close friend in Malmo, Sweden, who
says his Swedish friends believe it
was the CIA. The chief investigator,
Holmer, was convinced that it was a
Kurd. Many theories have surfaced in
the last twenty years. One Swedish
television documentary claimed that
there was an orchestrated police
conspiracy, including over a dozen men
on the streets that night with
walkie-talkies and two individual
policemen, identified with
photos. Jan Bondeson, author of
Blood on the Snow, writes: "a
multitude of suspects, all with
believable motives, form a long line
of ghostly killers waiting at the
Dekorima corner: a lone avenger, a
disgruntled Stockholm cop, a
right-wing extremist, a CIA agent, a
South African assassin, and a PKK
Kurd." Bondeson himself seems to
believe that the police deliberately
covered up a connection with the
Bofors arms trade, suggesting that the
killer was a South African assassin.
Is there a sinister
secret in Sweden, yet to be revealed?
Perhaps we will never know, but
meanwhile Swedish detective fiction is
thrilling the world with its
speculations.
Works Cited
Bondeson, Jan. Blood on the Snow:
the Killing of Olof Palme.
Ithaca and London: Cornell University
Press, 2005.
Dalsjo, Robert. Sweden's
squandered life-line to the West.
Zurich: Center for Security Studies,
2008. http://www.php.isn.ethz.ch.
Derfler, Leslie. The Fall and Rise
of Political Leaders: Olof Palme,
Olusegun Obasano, and Indira Gandhi.
New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2011.
Everman, Ron. The Cultural
Sociology of Political
Assassination: From MLK and RFK to
Fortuyn and Van Gogh. New York:
Palgrave Macmillan, 2011.
Sjowall, Maj, and Per Wahloo, The
Terrorists. Joan Tate, trans.
New York: Pantheon, 1976.
Stasio, Marilyn, "Cold Cases." New
York Times, September 17, 2010.
Elaine Kruse
Biography
Originally
from Illinois, Elaine Kruse received
her A.B. in history from Augustana
College in Rock Island, Illinois, and
her M.A. from the University of
Illinois. She completed her
Ph.D. in French history at the
University of Iowa after raising two
daughters.
She taught at
numerous colleges and universities
before settling at Nebraska Wesleyan
University in Lincoln, Nebraska, where
she taught European history and
civilization for twenty-four
years. Her "Visionaries,
Witches, and Madwomen" course was the
first the college had offered in
women's history.
An avid
traveler and an even more avid reader,
since her retirement she continues to
research and write on the early modern
period of France and England. She has
been a member of the Lincoln Torch
Club for twelve years.
Her paper was
originally presented in December 2012.
©2014 by the International
Association of Torch Clubs
Return to Home Page
|
|