The Torch Magazine,
The Journal and Magazine of the
International Association of Torch Clubs
For 94 Years
A Peer-Reviewed
Quality Controlled
Publication
ISSN Print 0040-9440
ISSN Online 2330-9261
Spring
2019
Volume 92, Issue 3
The
Continuity of Consciousness
by Deborah N.
Bauserman
In the dark recesses of a limestone
cave on the Indonesian island of
Sulawesi are found red and white
stencils of human hands. They
are the oldest known art depicting
humans in the world, a picture
postcard made nearly 40,000 years
ago. While archeologists are
uncertain of their function—to convey
important rituals, to invoke
protection, or to cast spells—our
ancient ancestor has sent us a simple,
undeniable message: "I am human. I
exist." It is the first recorded
spark of self-awareness.
As humans evolved, the spark of
consciousness blazed into a fierce
light shining on the minds of
philosophers, poets, mystics, and
artists, who inquired deeply into the
question of consciousness.
In the 6th century BC, Lao Tzu left
this record: "Without going outside,
you may know the whole world.
Without looking through the window,
you may see the ways of the heavens"
(50). Today, the insights
of these early explorers are being
investigated with sophisticated
technology and methodology by
scientists representing a whole array
of disciplines: physics, chemistry,
biology, physiology, and psychology.
Yet, for all the continuous
fascination with consciousness,
involving the brightest minds in the
arts and sciences, we have no very
complete understanding of its vast
potential. When we buy a digital
watch, we may receive an instruction
manual of 20 pages; however, at birth,
when we are endowed with the most
incredible tool of all, consciousness,
we get no instructions at all.
Commonly understood to be housed in
the brain, it gives a lifetime of
service managing sensory information,
remembering, dreaming, creating,
providing a sense of self and
connection to others, all with
unobtrusive efficiency. Yet,
after over 40,000 years of collective
experience with consciousness, we are
still without an operator's manual.
Although we only incompletely
understand the parameters of our
incredible gift, and although those
who study it produce conflicting
explanations, we will briefly consider
highlights of scientific study of
consciousness, followed by a few
noteworthy examples.
Let's begin with Charles Tart, an
acknowledged world authority in
consciousness studies. He points
out how much more than pure awareness
is involved: "Our ordinary state of
consciousness is not something natural
or given, but a highly complex
construction, a specialized tool for
coping with our environment and the
people in it" (3). That is, in
ordinary personal consciousness we
find a mixture of thoughts, fantasies,
ideas, and sensory information from
the external world geared to survival,
all significantly selected and limited
by cultural conditioning. In
addition, we experience things that
are not physically present such as
hallucinations, daydreams, and fruits
of imagination. At night we
dream and experience events and
objects that we totally produce by
ourselves.
To this incredible array are added
elements of life that lie outside
detectable ranges of perception:
energy in the electromagnetic band,
microscopic phenomena, very high- and
low-level sound waves, and infrared
radiation. We also generate our
own internal stimuli—buzzing thoughts,
familiar, peculiar or unnoticed
internal organ sensations, volitional
muscular activity, aches and pains,
variable emotions, and much
more. These processes are always
occurring simultaneously throughout
life, yet we from moment to moment we
are unaware of most of this
overwhelming input, thanks to the
filtering process of
consciousness.
Thus, personal consciousness cannot
fully represent the external or
internal world, but must consist of an
extremely small fraction of our entire
"reality." If we realize our
ordinary consciousness is something we
must construct in order to survive in
the world, then we can understand that
this consciousness is only one
possible consciousness. The
psychologist William James compared
this process to that of a sculptor
carving a statue out of stone.
The process largely involves many
levels of selection and consequent
limitation, so each individual
sculptor's statue is unique, just like
each person's consciousness.
Robert Ornstein, University of
California, San Francisco, stands out
as a pioneer in consciousness
studies. His foundational work
centered on the observation that right
and left hemispheres of the brain
control different aspects of
consciousness. For instance, the
left hemisphere of the brain is
understood to be in time, analytic,
linear, sequential, focal, verbal,
causal, and "masculine." In
contrast, the right hemisphere is
described as timeless, holistic,
non-lineal, simultaneous, spatial,
intuitive, synchronous, and
"feminine." As different as
night and day, they are often seen as
demarcating ordinary and non-ordinary
consciousness.
While current research upholds aspects
of hemispheric specialization,
neuroscientist sare discovering
greater integration between the
hemispheres than previously thought.
The formerly held position that the
brain is a physiologically static
organ has been replaced by the concept
of neuroplasticity, according to which
neural pathways and synapses may
change due to changes in behavior,
environment, neural processes,
thinking and emotion, as well as
changes from bodily injury. Jill Bolte
Taylor, a Harvard-trained
neuroanatomist, provides a riveting
account of her own left hemisphere
stroke, the gradual shut-down of her
brain functioning, and her eventual
recovery in her best-selling memoir, My
Stroke of Insight.
For an even broader model, we can look
to the work of Ken Wilber, one of
today's most influential
philosopher/psychologists. His
conceptual latticework, almost fractal
in beauty, proposes multiple elements
of consciousness: functions,
structures, states, modes,
developmental stages, and relational
interactions, a project so complex
that it really requires its own
paper.
Clearly, theoreticians and scientists
have no end of research topics in
sight.
*
* *
In academia, major divisions have
predictably split the research
community, almost in parallel to the
right-left split of the brain
itself. On one side are
conservative members who stand by
their belief that consciousness is
strictly a function of one's own brain
activity and ends at
death. In contrast are
equally convinced researchers who
follow ancient Buddhist belief as well
as contemporary quantum physics
research in maintaining that
separation is an illusion. For
them, consciousness is more than the
physical brain and can be empirically
shown to function as a transmitter for
nonlocal consciousness—broadly
speaking, the entire consciousness of
mankind and creation, untethered by
time and space. For this
community, the individual brain might
be compared to a radio playing
music—no orchestra inside!
The math on what constitutes ordinary
versus non-ordinary states of
consciousness is somewhat fuzzy, given
the enormous variability in individual
abilities. For example, for most
of us, imagery in ordinary
consciousness is likely to be unstable
and lack vividness, as when we head
out into a vast parking lot and try
vainly to picture where we left the
car. Others, such as the
inventor Nikola Tesla, enjoy imagery
that is vivid, intense and
controllable. When Tesla
designed a machine, he did it in his
head without using physical
drawings. Nevertheless, he could
instruct a dozen different machinists
how to make each separate part,
accurate to within a thousandth of an
inch, and the completed machine would
fit together perfectly.
Careful empirical observations and
even mathematical proofs,
historically, have not always swayed
strongly held beliefs, so the same may
be true for our modest primer of the
origins and mechanics of
consciousness. But, with at
least rudimentary descriptions of
consciousness in place, and given the
many interesting directions we might
pursue, we will now go on to consider
two examples of non-ordinary
consciousness gaining traction in some
research circles. Both examples
involve (l) valid empirical
research, (2) a teachable skill, and
(3) creating a positive societal
impact.
Let's start with remote viewing—the
ability to experience and describe
objects at distant places that are
blocked from ordinary perception. In a
typical protocol, given a specific
longitudinal and latitudinal
coordinate, the remote viewer is asked
to describe his or her perception of
what is there.
Recent interest in remote viewing
began in the l960s when Russell Targ,
then a graduate student in physics
(and future pioneer in laser
development and senior staff scientist
for Lockheed Missile and Space), began
to notice his gift for
precognition. Curiosity piqued,
he assembled an informal group of
experienced researchers who were
willing to share their own
introspections about non-ordinary
consciousness in experimental
situations. Their work
eventually led to creation of the
Stanford Research Institute
International (SRI) remote viewing
program. Surprising
evidence of the existence of the
nonlocal mind eventually came to the
attention of the U.S. government, the
CIA and a host of other governmental
agencies, where it was utilized as an
intelligence gathering technique
during the Cold War and remained
highly classified until the l990s.
Jack Anderson, syndicated columnist
for the Washington Post, was
an avid follower of the developing
field. He described a CIA
project titled "Grill Flame" carried
out by Harold Puthoff, formerly with
the National Security Agency, and
Targ. Given only the
coordinates of a remote location, Targ
was able to describe an airfield,
complete with such details as a large
gantry and crane at one end of the
field. The CIA was impressed but
critical. There was indeed an
airfield, the Soviet's ultra-secret
nuclear testing area in Kazakhstan,
but no gantry or crane. That is,
until the next series of U.S. spy
satellite photographs arrived.
Then, in fact, a gantry and crane were
observed, just as Targ had described
them.
Remote viewing sounds like a rare
gift, yet Joe McMoneagle, one of the
top remote viewers for SRI for nearly
two decades and the author of Remote
Viewing Secrets, believes anyone
can be taught the skill. Hella
Hammid, a photographer and regular
contributor to Life magazine was
invited to join the SRI team as a
"control" subject, having no
experience in so-called psychic
abilities. With training, Hammid
became an outstanding remote viewer
who beat the odds of one in a million
over nine trials in her
descriptions. In successive
studies she accurately described
objects hidden in wooden boxes, small
objects hidden in aluminum cans, and
even microscopic targets the size of a
dot, such as those used by spies to
conceal messages in letters. All
these viewings were carefully
evaluated and found to be
statistically significant.
Many years have passed since the
heyday of official, classified
government interest in remote viewing,
and more sophisticated technology has
taken its place. Is there still
a need for this skill? Targ
seems to think so, saying "we favor
the government being as well informed
as possible about what is happening
the world. We think this is one
of the best ways to prevent
war." He also holds that it has
wider potential social benefits,
citing studies showing information
breakthroughs in executive decision
making, futurist predictions, medical
diagnosis, and even space exploration
(for example, details about Jupiter
that were later confirmed by Pioneer
10).
Remote viewing as the ability to
receive information outside the sphere
of ordinary consciousness. To
look at the other side of the coin of
consciousness, what about sending
information—specifically, information
to enable healing with a present or
remote person? Indeed, new data
substantiating remote healing has
aspects in common with double blind
studies in remote viewing, showing
that all people have capacities to be
healers.
The first experts we call upon to
illustrate the power of intentionally
altering consciousness for the purpose
of healing are shamans. "Shaman"
is a word from the language of the
Tungus people in Siberia and has been
adopted widely by anthropologists such
as Michael Harner to refer to persons
in non-Western cultures who were
previously known by terms such as
"witch," "witch-doctor," "medicine
man," "sorcerer," "magic man," and
"seer." According to Harner,
shamans are the keepers of a body of
ancient techniques to achieve and
maintain well-being for themselves and
members of their communities. Because
these so-called primitive people
lacked our advanced level of medical
technology, they had excellent
motivation to develop capacities of
consciousness for health and
healing. Moreover, the basic
uniformity of shamanic methods, which
are strikingly similar in vastly
different cultures, suggests that
through trial and error people arrived
at the same conclusions around the
world.
The essential practice of the shaman
begins with a shift from what Harner
designates Ordinary States of
Consciousness (OSC) to Shamanic States
of Consciousness (SSC), the latter
being trance states that may be
facilitated by drumming, rattling, or
(sometimes) ingestion of sacred
potions of ayahuasca. The
differences between these states of
consciousness are suggested by the
role of animal guides: dragons,
griffins, and other animals
functioning as spirit guides that
would be considered "mythical" by us
in the OSC are "real" in the
SSC. Basically, what is real and
what is fantasy depends on the
person's state of consciousness.
A well-known example combining
shamanism with Western technological
medicine is the work of Dr. Simonton
and his wife in treating oncology
patients, originally at the Simonton
Cancer Center in Fort Worth, Texas.
(1) As a part of their treatment,
patients relax in a quiet room and
visualize themselves on a walking
journey until they meet an "inner
guide," which is a person or
animal. The patient then asks
the "guide" for help in getting well,
a process that closely resembles a
shamanic journey and the recovery of a
power animal. When the Simontons,
without suggesting content, had their
patients make drawings of their
cancers, they spontaneously drew
snakes and other creatures
surprisingly similar to those seen by
shamans as harmful intrusive powers in
the bodies of their patients.
Using these and other techniques,
patients were sometimes surprisingly
successful in gaining relief from pain
and other side effects of their
cancerous conditions.
At present, healing modalities using
shifts in consciousness in the
presence of the client include but are
not limited to energetic healing,
Reiki, Therapeutic Touch, pranic
healing and Chi Gong. (2)
(Alternations in consciousness
facilitated by LSD and psilocybin, by
the way, are making a comeback for
treatment of intractable pain and end
of life comfort, as explored in
Michael Pollan's recent book, How
to Change Your Mind.)
Psychic healers and those trained in
energetic healing have also shown
ability to manipulate symptoms with
their mind from a distance. For
evidence that anyone can learn remote
healing, your author has had
first-hand experience and offers the
following example.
In 2010, when the author was enrolled
in a year-long study of energetic
healing, (3) a fellow student whom we
shall call Pam (a biochemist and the
CEO of a healthcare consulting company
in Maryland) suffered three broken
bones and a concussion after falling
from a cliff during a hike. Pam
had the presence of mind to call the
group and ask for help from the
emergency room. Healing energies
were immediately directed to her for
the next two days the group was
meeting, followed by telephone contact
to receive feedback from our subject
about results; she reported that she
needed no pain medication after the
first day and rapidly regained
function in all areas. At the
two-week follow-up with her surgeon,
the nurse was apologetic that their
department seemed to have lost her
x-rays. The x-rays they
possessed depicted her fractures, her
name and other identifying
information, but the fracture sites
were consistent with eight, not two,
weeks of recovery. The surgeon
appeared later with a group of interns
and was quite interested to learn
about the strategies producing such
remarkable results.
Like so many other areas of
non-ordinary expressions of
consciousness, the causal mechanisms
of various forms of psychic and remote
healing are not known, yet the
results, for those who experience
them, are profound. Opportunities for
expansion of personal consciousness
are numerous and freely available
through the practice of disciplines
such as meditation, contemplative
prayer, self-hypnosis, yoga, or
taijichuan.
Before we conclude, mention ought to
be made of a hypnotic technique known
as age regression, which reveals the
continuity of consciousness from
lifetime to lifetime. Evidence
of reincarnation is now
well-documented in mainstream medical
journals, general audience
publications, and even the national
evening news. Chief contributors
are Ian Stevenson and Jim Tucker of
the University of Virginia, who have
completed decades of research into
children's memories of previous
lives. Just around the corner,
new credibility may be in store for
techniques enabling adults to recall
their past lives and their experiences
between lives as pure consciousness.
Accessing these states with skilled
practitioners has been to shown to
alleviate persistent physical and
emotional symptoms otherwise
unresponsive to traditional medical
treatment.
To conclude, what about that missing
operator's guide to
consciousness? Let's take a cue
from the great poet Emily Dickinson,
herself an intrepid explorer of
consciousness from the narrow confines
of her Amherst family home:
Go thy
great way!
The stars thou
meetest
Are even as
Thyself –
For what are
Stars but Asterisks
To point a human
life?
Notes
(1)
The Simonton Cancer Center's
integrated program was the first of
its kind in the world and was
pioneered by the "father of mind-body
medicine" for cancer, O. Carl
Simonton, M.D.
(2) Pranic
healing is a comprehensive no touch
treatment technique based on ancient
practices and uses energy or prana to
treatment various illnesses in the
physical, emotional and mental bodies.
Taichichuan is an internal Chinese
martial art practiced for its defense
training and its health benefits
(3) The
year-long training in energetic
healing took place under the auspices
of the White Winds Institute, Atlanta,
GA, in the satellite study center then
in Edinberg, VA, directed by Dr.
Fernand Poulin.
Works Cited
Bolte Taylor,
J. My Stroke of Insight: A
Brain Scientist's Personal Journey.
NY: Viking, 2008.
Dickinson, Emily. The Poems of
Emily Dickinson, No.1673.
Edited by R. W. Franklin.
Cambridge, MA: Harvard UP , l999.
Grof, S. Psychology of the
Future: Lessons from Modern
Consciousness Research. SUNY
Press, 2000.
Harner, M. The Way of the
Shaman, NY: Harper and Row, 1980.
McMoneagle, J. Remote Viewing
Secrets: A Handbook.
Charlottesville, VA: Hampton Roads
Publishing, 2000.
Ornstein, R.E. The Psychology
of Consciousness. Second
Edition. NY: Harcourt Brace
Jovanovich, l977.
Targ, R., and Katra, J.
Miracles of Mind: Exploring
Nonlocal Consciousness and Spiritual
Healing. Novato, CA: New
World Library, l998.
Targ, R., and Puthoff, H.E.
Mind-Reach: Scientists Look at
Psychic Abilities. Charlottesville,
VA: Hampton Roads Publishing,
2005. Originally published
Delacorte Press, 1977.
Tart, C.T. States of
Consciousness. Authors Guild
Backinprint.com Edition, 2000.
Originally published by Dutton, 1975.
Tzu, Lao. Tao Te Ching. Tr.
Gia-Fu Feng, Jane English, and Toinette
Lippe. NY: Vintage, 1997.
Walker, C. "The First Artists." National
Geographic vol. 227, no. 1
(January 2015), p. 41ff.
Warcollier, R. Mind to Mind.
NY: Creative Age Press, 1948.
Wilber, K. Integral
Psychology: Consciousness,
Spirit, Psychology, Therapy.
Boston: Shambhala, 2000.
Author's
Biography
Deborah Bauserman is a native of East
Grand Rapids, Michigan, and completed
degrees at
Michigan State University (B.A, M.A),
the University of Northern Colorado
(Ed.D), and the
University of Virginia (post-doctoral
studies).
She retired in 2016 after more than 40
years as a Licensed Clinical
Psychologist in a private
practice located in Winchester,
Virginia.
She was for many years an active
volunteer in organizations supporting
the arts, environment
and historic preservation. Her hobbies
include practicing taichichuan, yoga,
riding and driving
horses, and art. She continues to
enjoy farm work involving running a
tractor, chain saw,
mowing, and anything other than going
to the gym.
She is married to Steve Bauserman, and
they have two sons and two
grandchildren. Since
1998 she has been a member of
Winchester Torch Club, where she
presented this paper in June,
2016.
She may be reached at
deb_bauserman@yahoo.com
©2019
by the International Association of
Torch Clubs
Return to Home Page
|
|