data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/aa87a/aa87ac90a7b5340a6f568bdc45d7dcc0e5334fea" alt="Torch Logo"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e8637/e8637ab92fefe7b2e892fdfa1a16a11c30e091f9" alt="Magazine Logo"
The Torch Magazine,
The Journal and Magazine of the
International Association of Torch Clubs
For 96 Years
A Peer-Reviewed
Quality Controlled
Publication
ISSN Print 0040-9440
ISSN Online 2330-9261
Fall
2020
Volume 94, Issue 1
The
Multitudes of "What-if"
by Anthony
Anderson
Gene
Roddenberry sold Star Trek: The
Original Series (TOS) to NBC by
painting the show as "a western in
space." Instead of riding horses,
however, the main characters of Star
Trek
rode the U.S.S. Enterprise,
galloping amongst the cosmos instead of
the tumbleweeds, hopping solar systems
instead of mountains, and reaching the
end of the universe instead of the
Pacific. The new frontier of the wild
west having already been explored, Star
Trek promised to take viewers on
adventures of the final frontier: outer
space. The show introduced countless
alien races, made thousands of new
discoveries, and surpassed flight-speeds
never thought possible. In reality,
though, the frontier Star Trek
explored had nothing to do with space.
Instead, in episode after episode,
series after series, movie after movie,
it showed its audience the frontier of
humanity's future. The future of
humanity in space, yes, but also the
future to a society with an advanced
sensibility and the common goal to work
for the good of all.
Star Trek
brought this future to television sets
across the United States as one of the
first science fiction shows ever aired.
The science-fiction genre, also called
speculative fiction, typically depicts
humanity in the near or far future, 300
years in the future in the case of Star
Trek. The show looked forward, but
this type of progressive expression came
before its time. As a result, Star
Trek came all too close to not
coming at all.
NBC ordered the first pilot, called "The
Cage," which depicts a race of people,
the Taloasians, who want to use their
incredible ability to create a menagerie
for the USS Enterprise's Captain
Christopher Pike. NBC rejected the
pilot. They said the show required too
much intellect for common television
audiences to enjoy. With the rejection
came a rare request from the network.
Scott Tipton, writer and editor of Star
Trek Vault, observed "the NBC
executives must have been impressed,"
because they asked Roddenberry to write
a second pilot. NBC realized, as
Roddenberry knew, that Star Trek
offered something special, something
other television shows could not. It
offered an alternative setting in which
humanity could observe itself in the
multitudes of "what if."
Star Trek could
take stock of the present, with all its
problems, and draw on the imagination to
depict a brighter future. What if a man
from Iowa could lead a crew with a
Scottish chief engineer, a Russian
weapon's officer, an African-American
woman at the communication's station, a
man of Japanese descent piloting the
ship, and an alien half-breed serving as
science and first officer across the
uncharted reaches of space? The
"what-if" served as a goal for the human
condition. At the time the show aired,
The Civil Rights Act had just been
passed, and the United States and Soviet
Union stared across the sea at each
other in the darkest days of the Cold
War. The beginnings of the Vietnam War
thwarted peace, and more women worked
outside the home. The 1960s required
people think forward, of what could be
and what should be. Star Trek
helped people see "what-if" play out in
a way which led not to death and
destruction, but instead, to a
fundamental evolution to the human
condition.
*
* *
Star Trek imagines the future as
a time when we have made many kinds of
progress, but not all science fiction
does this. Recent science fiction plays
on our fears more often than on our
hopes. As a society, pessimism and
cynicism from the news people hear, the
literature people read, and the violence
people see poisons humanity's ability to
understand the future as a time not
written. The "dystopia," a popular genre
today, is based on this pessimistic view
of what's yet to come. Authors have
released countless dystopias, from
Winston Smith's world of thought-crimes
and doublespeak in Orwell's 1984
to The Hunger Games' Panem,
built on the lands of the once United
States of America. Movies and television
shows portray this fear, too. The
Matrix suggests humanity lives,
at present, in a computer simulation
controlled by artificial intelligence
humans once controlled themselves. Even
fare for the whole family, such as Wall-e,
the Disney-Pixar film, predicts humanity
will so pollute the Earth that humans
will have to evacuate and recolonize the
planet after it has centuries to
recover. The dystopian media gives
justification to people's grim view of
humanity's own future.
Often, the
creators of these bleak visions
exacerbate the problems of the present
day to found their worlds in truth. The
author of Ready Player One, Ernest
Cline, predicted a future in which
humanity runs out of fossil fuels:
We
used up most of this fuel before you
got here, and now it's pretty much all
gone. This means that we no longer
have enough energy to keep our
civilization running like it was
before. So we've had to cut back.
Big-time. We call this the Global
Energy Crisis, and it's been going on
for a while now (17).
In a book called Golden
State by Ben H. Winters, published
in January 2019, a new society built on
the grounds of California lives apart
from the United States, which has been
destroyed by nuclear radiation, the
effects of which "were compounded by the
inability/unwillingness of survivors to
communicate [i.e. a severe distrust
toward fellow survivors, refusal to
accept or solicit assistance,
presumption of "enemy intent"] (313). In
these future worlds of humanity, the
problem of fossil fuel dependence turns
into a crisis, and both the wielding of
nuclear bombs and the general suspicion
of one another destroy society and keep
people apart. This inability to trust
one another forces the society Winters
creates to adopt laws against lying—laws
punishable by death. The beginnings of
what could be humanity's undoing serve
as the premise for the dystopian futures
people read and watch, and audiences
take in these dystopias because they,
too, look at the human condition of the
present and aggravate it in their
predictions of the future.
Star Trek
defies dystopia. It looks at humanity's
future and says it will become wiser and
more just than it is now. It provides a
now rarely-seen view of the landscape in
front of humanity. Rather than an ashen
ground stretched for miles ahead, Star
Trek sees the grass grow
greener and healthier with each passing
mile. All of its optimism stems, like
the pessimism of the dystopias, from the
foundations of present realities. Unlike
the dystopias, however, Star Trek sees
the realities of the present as
challenges humanity will be able to meet
rather than as a fate it cannot escape.
Not every episode weighed morality and
ethics, but every one of them showed the
exploration that awaits humanity.
*
* *
So, how does Star
Trek use the present to inform its
future?
In February
1967, an episode called "A Taste of
Armageddon" exemplified Star Trek's
extrapolation from current events to
inform plots that takes place in a
possible future. In the episode, the Enterprise
visits Eminiar VII, and as they approach
the planet, the ship receives a
communication from the planet telling
them not to approach. The Enterprise
approaches anyway, and when they
transport to the planet, they learn the
Enterprise has been destroyed in
an attack. In actuality, the attack did
not damage the Enterprise after
all, as Captain Kirk and company
understand once they realize that the
planet has split into two factions that
fight each other with virtual weapons.
The two sides fire virtual missiles at
each other, and a computer simulation
projects impact zones. All of the
residents in those zones then go to a
center where they report to die as
casualties of war. Since the Enterprise
has been hit, the leaders of one side
claims the Enterprise crew
members still aboard must come down to
the planet to be executed. This virtual
war, which Captain Kirk learns has raged
on this planet for 500 years, serves as
an analogy for another type of war.
When the show
came out in 1966 and throughout its
entire run, the United States and the
Soviet Union battled off the battlefield
to create the bigger bomb, the better
soldier, and the best space program. As
the arsenal of weapons continued to
stockpile, the war the US never fought
grew closer to being the war that ended
it. In no other decade did the United
States come so close to entering an
armed conflict with the Soviet Union
than the 1960's. So, amongst this
atmosphere of fear, Star Trek
comes out with the analogy of a virtual
war in place of The Cold War. At the end
of the episode, Captain Kirk destroys
one of the centers to which people
report to die as casualties of war. The
leader of one faction says to Kirk, "You
realize what you have done?" To which,
Kirk responds:
Yes, I
do. I've given you back the horrors of
war. The Vendikans now assume that
you've broken your agreement and that
you're preparing to wage real war with
real weapons. They'll want do the
same. Only the next attack they launch
will do a lot more than count up
numbers in a computer. They'll destroy
cities, devastate your planet. You of
course will want to retaliate. If I
were you, I'd start making bombs. Yes,
Councilman, you have a real war on
your hands. You can either wage it
with real weapons, or you might
consider an alternative. Put an end to
it. Make peace.
Later, Spock,
Captain Kirk's renowned first officer,
says, "Captain, you took a big chance."
To which, Kirk responds:
It was
a calculated risk. Still, the Eminians
keep a very orderly society, and
actual war is a very messy business. A
very, very messy business. I had a
feeling that they would do anything to
avoid it, even talk peace.
The obvious Cold
War connection to this episode
exemplifies a Star Trek-ism—the
recurring motif of the crew of the Enterprise
coming across a planet or a civilization
fighting the same battle humans have
fought in the past.
With an
awareness of the events of the present,
Star Trek writers looked to the
future to offer a commentary on how a
human race with advanced sensibility
might look at the human condition at the
time of the episode's creation. "A Taste
of Armageddon" offered the idea of how
an enduring cold war would affect
America's society. On Eminiar VII, the
citizens of the world submitted to the
idea of a virtual war, and they would
report without fail to the centers in
which they died as casualties of war. In
a way, America's culture started to
accept the enemy. It practiced drills in
schools where students would hide under
their desks. It practiced launch drills
for its arsenal of nuclear weapons. It
postulated the idea of Star Wars, the
advanced missile defense system which
would have stopped Soviet weapons in the
atmosphere. The Cold War became part of
America's identity for 46 years.
Although it did not last 500 years like
the virtual war on Eminiar VII, it did
last long enough to change the way US
society functioned. This Star Trek
episode, aired early in the cold war but
at its most serious time, predicted what
a war of this nature could do.
*
* *
By the time the
sixth and final movie with the original
cast came out in 1991, the tensions of
the Cold War had all but vanished as
America's long-time political enemy had
collapsed. Star Trek chose to
symbolize the end of the Soviet Union
not as a collapse, however, but as a new
alliance. In the original series of the
1960s, Klingons represented the Soviets,
the constant aggressor, the constant
competition. In Star Trek VI: The
Undiscovered Country, 1991, the
Klingons suffer a massive explosion on a
satellite of their home planet, Kronos.
The explosion will cause the atmosphere
of the Klingon home world to
disintegrate to the point of
uninhabitability. Because of these
events, the Klingons have come to the
table to discuss peace. Though this
peace looks so close to not happening in
the movie, it does, and so brings an end
to, as Spock says, "nearly 70 years of
unrelenting hostility, which the
Klingons can no longer afford." Captain
Kirk sums up the feeling of the United
States and the Soviet Union well when,
at the end of the movie, he says to the
chancellor of the Klingon Empire, who
was anointed upon her father's
assassination, "It's about the future,
Madam Chancellor. Some people think the
future means the end of history. But we
haven't run out of history just yet.
Your father called the future 'the
undiscovered country.' People can be
very frightened of change." The fear of
change, the fear of the future makes
dystopias a best-selling genre. But Star
Trek shows humanity that change does not
mean the end, but as Captain Kirk says,
"we haven't run out of history just
yet." And, as Star Trek's
timeline goes, it shows its audience how
easily once enemies can become friends.
It showed as
much when a Klingon serves aboard the
bridge of the Enterprise-D in Star
Trek: The Next Generation (TNG,) which
premiered four years before The
Undiscovered Country, in 1987.
Throughout the second incarnation of Star
Trek, the peace between the
Federation and Klingons threatens to
unravel, but as friends do, the Klingons
and Federation keep the peace. In one
episode of TNG, "Yesterday's
Enterprise," the writers explore the
outcome of a scenario in which peace
between the Federation and the Klingons
never occurred. Lori Maguire, a
Professor of British and American
Studies at the University of Paris and
an interested "Trekkie," writes,
"'Yesterday's Enterprise' reflects on
what might have happened if the Cold War
had become hot, showing the Federation
engaged in a long, probably losing war
with the Klingons" (76). The episode
ends with the proper timeline restored,
but it leaves a taste of how a conflict
with the Soviet Union could have
devastated the United States. Luckily,
no such conflict came to be, and the
once enemy, the Klingons, became the
Federation of Planets' friends.
Peace with the
Klingons meant The Next Generation could
explore other pressing political issues,
and it did. But in addition to using the
present as a lens for the future, Star
Trek gave humanity a taste of the
moral and ethical superiority towards
which we could aspire. The first episode
of the new series featured a supposedly
omnipotent, omniscient character named Q
who puts humanity on trial, saying
"Before this gracious court now appear
these prisoners to answer for the
multiple and grievous savageries of
their species." Captain Picard asks for
specific charges, and Q provides a list,
which the audience does not get to see,
presumably listing every time humans
acted savagely. Picard recognizes
humanity's past, but he asks Q to test
whether the charges filed against the
human race are still true, to which Q
agrees. But the trial does not end at
the end of the episode. The trial
continues, throughout the entire series,
until the last episode, which bookends
the first. Captain Picard and Q again
appear in the courtroom from the first
episode of the series, and when it
appears a resolution has been reached,
Captain Picard says, "I sincerely hope
that this is the last time that I find
myself here." To which, Q responds, "You
just don't get it, do you, Jean-Luc? The
trial never ends." The message here,
that though humanity has shown itself to
be a "grievously savage race" in its
past, humanity evolves as time goes on
to better itself and its intentions. Star
Trek writers here establish an
idea, one which is hard to confirm given
events in the news, that humanity learns
from its past and improves for the
future. The past, according to Star
Trek, does not define the race, it
helps it grow, morally and ethically as
well as technologically.
*
* *
Another facet
of Star Trek, besides its
obvious parallels to the present that
resonates with fans and distinguishes it
from other science-fiction works,
especially dystopias, is how it presents
humanity's future as a time of
enlightenment. In the future world of Star
Trek, humans have surpassed the
speed of light, cured cancer, rid
society of money and thereby the pursuit
of financial gain, and they have united
the planet of Earth. As a result, humans
travel amongst the stars, because this
advancement, this evolution in humanity,
means humans spend no time sparring with
each other and can focus their joint
energies on the greater cause. That is,
humans can work towards betterment,
constantly and unceasingly. The humans
of Star Trek are not
infallible, but they can recognize their
mistakes and continue to grow from them,
not just individually but as a race.
People have
reasons to think humanity can make it
out of any dark spot, and Star Trek
highlights society's progress. David
Deutsch, a professor of physics at
Oxford University, writes in his book
The Beginning of Infinity, "An
optimistic civilization is open and not
afraid to innovate, and is based on
traditions of criticism. Its
institutions keep improving, and the
most important knowledge that they
embody is knowledge of how to detect and
eliminate errors" (quoted in Pinker, 7).
Deutsch feels, as Star Trek
shows, that society has reached a point
of enlightenment it has never reached
before, and as time goes on, humanity
will continue to improve, realizing its
mistakes and growing from them.
A view of a future
such as this should not seem
unattainable. It should not look
impossible. A view of a future such as
this should give hope. In the 1960s, the
United States needed an outlet for its
fears where it could seek comfort in a
positive future. Today, the
uncertainties of the world make Star
Trek as relevant as it was in the
tumult of then. The manifest destiny
humans have for space stems not from
scientific ambitions; it stems from a
hope for humanity's future. In
dystopias, the problems of today become
the crises of tomorrow. In Star Trek,
human ingenuity and ever-evolving
sensibility solves the problems of today
and continues to solve new problems
tomorrow and the next day and the next
day, boldly going where no one has gone
before. At the end of the series Star
Trek: The Next Generation, the
omnipotent, omniscient Q tells Captain
Picard, "That is the exploration that
awaits you. Not mapping stars and
studying nebulae, but charting the
unknowable possibilities of existence."
Star Trek helps its audience see,
while examining the human condition of
the present, the unknown possibilities,
the multitudes of "what if," that await
humanity in the future.
Works Cited
"All Good Things." Star Trek: The Next
Generation. Writ. Ronal D. Moore and
Brannon Braga. Dir. Winrich Kolbe.
Paramount, 1994.
"A Taste of Armageddon." Star Trek: The
Original Series. Writ. Robert Hamner and
Gene L. Coon. Dir. Joseph Pevney.
Paramount, 1967.
Cline, Ernest. Ready Player One.
New York: Crown Publishers , 2011.
Maguire, Lori. "The Final Reflection?: A
Mirror Empire?" Reagin, Nancy R. Star
Trek and History. Hoboken: John
Wiley and Sons , 2013. 71-86.
Pinker, Steven. Enlightenment Now:
The Case for Reason, Science,
Humanism, and Progress. New York:
Penguin Random House, 2018.
Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered
Country. Dir. Nicholas Meyer.
Perf. William Shatner. Paramount. 1991.
DVD.
Winters, Ben H. Golden State.
New York: Mullholland Books, 2019.
Author's Biography
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5b2f4/5b2f4b34c87a8e0a44c59d5189d9a544a7e50896" alt="Anderson photo"
Born and raised in Lincoln,
Nebraska, where he still lives,
Anthony Anderson earned a bachelor's
degree at Nebraska Wesleyan
University, and is currently
pursuing a master's degree in
English at the University of
Nebraska, Kearney. He teaches
English at Lincoln Northeast High
School.
He and his
wife and I will celebrate their
three-year anniversary this
year. They have a dog named Finn and
two cats, Riker and Data.
He joined
the Tom Carroll Lincoln Torch Club
as an undergraduate, beneficiary of
a special outreach program for
college students. "The Multitudes of
What-If" was delivered to to that
club on April 15, 2019.
He may be
reached at alphatango1996@gmail.com.
Return to Home Page
|
|